Texas Law and News Blog

Marketing Defects Can Kill: The Texas Weevil-Cide Case

If you’re not in the legal profession, the idea of a marketing defect lawsuit probably sounds strange—perhaps even frivolous. However, marketing defect suits aren’t about ineffective marketing or overselling a product. Marketing defect claims arise in a product liability suit when failure to provide adequate warnings or instructions for safe use results in harm to the purchaser or others. Often, this type of claim is described as a “failure to warn” case.

A product liability suit filed by a northern Texas family recently illustrates the dangers of inadequate warnings and the type of harm that may lead to a marketing defect claim.

Texas Couple Sues Pesticide Manufacturer after Poisoning Death of Four Children

Last January, a Potter County father used Weevil-Cide under the house where his family resided. The product, a commercial-grade pesticide, included several warnings on its label, including a notice that the product should be used only by a Certified Applicator or someone working under the direct supervision of a Certified Applicator. Most significantly, the label included a bold, all-caps statement prohibiting use of the product within 100 feet of a building where humans or domestic animals dwell.

Unfortunately, these warnings were printed only in English, a language the plaintiff does not speak. Instead, the label contained a small warning, in regular type amidst several lines of bold-faced, all-caps, large-sized and red warnings in English, that cautioned non-English speakers to have the label explained to them before using the product.

Four of the couple’s children, aged 7-17, died from exposure to toxic fumes. Several others present in the home were hospitalized, but survived.

It remains for the Potter County Court to determine whether including a warning that non-English-speaking users should have the label translated before proceeding constitutes an adequate warning. However, the tragic outcome in this case serves to illustrate just how serious the impact of a marketing defect can be.

What is a Marketing Defect Under Texas Law?

A marketing defect is one type of product liability claim. A marketing defect claim may be filed alone, or in combination with other product liability claims. Marketing defect cases most commonly arise when the manufacturer or seller of a product:

  • Fails to provide important warnings, or provides warnings that are inadequate
  • Fails to provide instructions for safe use of the product, or provides inadequate instructions

A marketing defect claim may also arise when the labeling and other marketing associated with a product misleads consumers into believing that the product is safer than it is, or that the manufacturer is sanctioning uses that are in fact unsafe.

The Impact of Marketing Defect Cases

One of the highest profile failure to warn cases in the U.S. resulted in a 2002 verdict against cigarette manufacturer Philip Morris for failure to warn of the risks associated with smoking. The plaintiff in that case was a 67-year-old patient who had been smoking for 50 years, beginning long before mandatory warnings and public information campaigns ensured that the public had information about the health risks associated with cigarette smoking.
Public perception is often that both warning labels and product liability suits go too far. While it’s easy to laugh at the occasional “don’t grab knife by the blade” type warning on products we purchase or roll your eyes at the idea that McDonald’s should have warned customers that eating Big Macs on a regular basis wasn’t healthy, clear, adequate warnings and instructions save lives. Manufacturing defect claims, like other types of product liability claims, can have a significant impact on labeling practices and, thus, consumer safety.

Product Liability Claims are Complicated

When you’ve been injured by a defective product or because a manufacturer or seller failed to provide appropriate warnings or instructions, it can be difficult to know how to move forward. Product liability cases are complex, and generally require a significant investment of resources. This is understandably daunting to most people, particularly while they are dealing with the impact of a serious injury or the loss of a loved one.

A law firm with a background in product liability claims can help by:

  • Assessing available claims
  • Identifying possible responsible parties
  • Retaining experts and investigators to build your case
  • Managing complicated procedural requirements
  • Building a strong case on your behalf

You don’t have to go it alone. Call 800-298-0111 right now to schedule a free consultation and learn more about how we can put our experience to work for you.