Key Takeaways: What Every Defective Medical Device Victim Should Know
- You have two years from injury discovery to file a defective medical device lawsuit in Texas under Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code Section 16.003, though federal preemption may affect certain claims.
- Multiple parties may be liable including manufacturers, distributors, and sometimes doctors who failed to warn about known risks.
- FDA recalls don’t guarantee compensation but can strengthen your case by establishing that the device was known to be dangerous. Medical device recalls reached a four-year high in 2024, with 1,059 events recorded.
- Preserve your device and medical records immediately as this evidence is crucial for proving your case against the manufacturer.
- Some cases join multidistrict litigation (MDL) while others proceed individually, depending on the specific device and circumstances.
Contact a Houston defective medical device attorney today for your free case evaluation. Our experienced product liability lawyers will help you understand your rights with no pressure or obligation.
Why Choose Simmons & Fletcher After a Medical Device Injury in Houston?
When a medical device that was supposed to help you instead causes serious harm, you need experienced Houston defective medical device attorneys who understand the complex laws governing product liability claims. At Simmons & Fletcher, P.C., we have been fighting for injured Texans since 1979.
Our track record speaks for itself:
- Paul H. Cannon is Board Certified in Personal Injury Trial Law by the Texas Board of Legal Specialization;
- We have recovered millions of dollars for our clients;;
- Our attorneys have been recognized as Texas Super Lawyers by Thomson Reuters;
- We exclusively represent injured patients: never medical device manufacturers or insurance companies.
If we accept your defective medical device case, our Houston product liability attorneys will:
- Provide a thorough free case evaluation with no obligation;
- Investigate the device manufacturer’s safety record and FDA communications;
- Work with medical experts to prove the device caused your injuries;
- Handle all communications with insurance companies and corporate defendants;
- Fight for maximum compensation while you focus on your health and recovery;
- Take your case to trial if necessary to secure fair compensation.
Get legal help from experienced medical device failure attorneys today. Call (713) 932-0777 for your free consultation. You pay no attorney fees unless we win your case.
4.9 out of 5 stars based on 486 reviews on Google, see what our clients say about us
Irma G.
Simmons and Fletcher was a very nice and friendly law firm from the moment I went in for my initial consult. A big thank you to all of them for hearing me out and agreeing…
Amber R.
Simmons and fletcher law firm. Went above and beyond for me. I was in a bad wreck that requires neck surgery. They constantly called and checked on me to see how I was doing. They…
Sue M.
I guess we are all a bit hesitant to have to hire a lawyer, at least I know I was, but Simmons and Fletcher PC was highly recommended by a trusted friend so I decided…
Miriam F.
I cannot express enough what this firm has done for me and my family! From the very beginning my legal assistant, Jeannette, was there to guide me every step of the way. She kept me…
Rebecca D.
This office helped us out tremendously. Everyone we dealt with was professional and courteous. They were quick to respond to any questions regarding the process. I would definitely recommend these attorneys.
Oscar M.
I had a great experience at Simmons and Fletcher. They fought continuously in my case and always hand my best interest in me. Ruth was kind and attentive to my needs. She was always available…
Theresia R.
This firm did an excellent job in representing our family. Not only are they very knowledgeable but are also very polite and always communicated through the whole process. A special thank you to Amanda for…
Rebecca S.
I cannot recommend this firm enough. Chris Fletcher represented me and my experience was great from start to finish. Chris was honest, accessible, and easy to talk to. His paralegal, Stephanie Quinn, was also incredibly…
Sandra W.
I had a great experience with Simmons and Fletcher. Sharon Simmons Cantrell did an exceptional job on my case. She was attentive and sweet and fought hard for me. I would recommend her and the…
Christashaia J.
I would recommend Simmons and Fletcher to anyone! From start to finish my case was handled properly! Amanda Johnston handle my case so well, as well as communicated with me throughout the entire ordeal, and…
Veda J.
“After the accident I was really shaken to my core. Being a senior citizen, I wasn’t sure just what to do. I saw your tv ad and I decided to call. So glad I did…
Types of Defective Medical Devices
Our Houston defective medical device lawyers represent individuals affected by a broad spectrum of faulty medical devices that have resulted in injuries across Texas. Every day, nearly 2,000 new incidents related to medical devices are reported to the FDA’s MAUDE database, contributing to several hundred thousand reports annually. These cases highlight the significant impact that defective medical products can have on patient safety and well-being.
Implants (Hip, Knee, Cardiac)
Orthopedic and cardiac implants are designed to last for years, but design flaws and manufacturing defects can cause premature failure:
- Stryker hip implants with metal-on-metal components that release toxic metal particles;
- Knee replacement systems with premature wear causing pain and mobility issues;
- Cardiac devices including pacemakers and defibrillators with battery or lead failures;
- Exactech shoulder implants with packaging defects leading to accelerated wear.
Pumps, Meshes & Stents
These devices often involve direct contact with internal organs and can cause severe complications when defective:
- Transvaginal mesh used for pelvic organ prolapse causing erosion and chronic pain;
- Hernia mesh that shrinks, migrates, or causes adhesions requiring revision surgery;
- IVC filters that break apart and travel to vital organs;
- Insulin pumps with dosing errors or mechanical failures;
- Coronary stents that cause vessel re-narrowing or thrombosis.
We also handle cases involving Philips CPAP machines and Bard PowerPort catheters that have caused serious patient injuries.
Find out if your medical device injury qualifies for compensation. Contact our Houston product liability attorneys for a free case review today.
Common Device Failures
Medical device injuries typically result from one of three types of product defects that make the device unreasonably dangerous for patients.
Design Defects & Manufacturing Errors
Design defects affect entire product lines and occur when the device’s blueprint itself is flawed:
- Metal-on-metal hip implants that inherently release toxic cobalt and chromium;
- Surgical mesh made from materials incompatible with human tissue;
- IVC filters with design features that increase fracture risk.
Manufacturing errors happen during production and may affect specific batches:
- Contaminated devices due to poor sterile manufacturing processes;
- Incorrectly sized components that don’t fit properly;
- Quality control failures that allow defective units to reach patients.
Premature Wear & Malfunctions
Many defective medical devices fail earlier than expected, causing patients to need revision surgeries or emergency interventions:
- Hip and knee implants that loosen within years instead of lasting decades;
- Cardiac device batteries that deplete unexpectedly;
- Surgical mesh that deteriorates and fragments inside the body;
- Catheter systems that develop cracks or blockages.
These premature failures often occur because manufacturers prioritized profits over patient safety during development and testing.
Regulation and Recall Overview
Understanding FDA oversight helps explain why dangerous medical devices reach the market and harm patients.
FDA Approval & Warning Letters
The Food and Drug Administration regulates medical devices through different approval pathways:
- 510(k) clearance allows devices “substantially equivalent” to existing products without extensive safety testing;
- Premarket approval (PMA) requires more rigorous clinical trials for high-risk devices;
- Warning letters cite manufacturers for regulatory violations but don’t immediately remove devices from market.
Unfortunately, information provided to the FDA during approval is not always accurate. Manufacturers sometimes withhold critical safety data, leading to approval of dangerous devices.
Voluntary and Mandatory Recalls
When the FDA determines a medical device poses serious health risks, it can issue recalls. Sedgwick’s “2025 US State of the Nation Recall Index report” highlights the fact that medical device recalls reached a four-year high in 2024 with 1,059 events recorded, and Class I recalls are at a 15-year high. According to analysis of the FDA’s recall data:
- Voluntary recalls occur when manufacturers agree to remove products from the market;
- Mandatory recalls are rare but happen when companies refuse to voluntarily recall dangerous devices;
- Class I recalls involve devices that could cause serious injury or death.
Important: A recall doesn’t automatically mean you have a lawsuit, but it can strengthen your case by proving the manufacturer knew the device was dangerous.
Steps to Take After a Device Injury
Your actions immediately after discovering a medical device injury can significantly impact your ability to recover compensation.
Seeking Medical Treatment & Revision Surgery
Your health comes first. If you suspect your medical device is causing problems:
- Contact your doctor immediately about your symptoms;
- Get imaging studies or blood tests to assess device function;
- Consider seeking a second opinion from another specialist;
- Follow all medical advice regarding revision surgery or device removal;
- Document all symptoms, treatments, and medical expenses.
Preserving the Device & Medical Records
Evidence preservation is crucial for defective medical device lawsuits:
- Keep the removed device if revision surgery is performed. Don’t let the hospital dispose of it;
- Collect all medical records including pre-implant consultations, surgical notes, and follow-up visits;
- Save device packaging and documentation including model numbers, lot numbers, and manufacturer information;
- Take photographs of any visible injuries or complications;
- Keep receipts for all medical expenses and related costs.
Preserve evidence for your case immediately. Contact our Houston defective medical device lawyers to ensure critical evidence isn’t lost or destroyed.
Who Is Liable in Medical Device Cases?
Multiple parties may bear responsibility when a defective medical device causes patient harm, and we investigate all potential defendants.
Manufacturers & Distributors
Device manufacturers are typically the primary defendants in medical device lawsuits. Under Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code Chapter 82, the following may be held liable:
- Design companies that created the flawed device specifications;
- Manufacturing companies that produced the defective units;
- Parent corporations that own or control the device companies;
- Distributors and sales representatives who may have known about defects but continued marketing the device.
Doctors and Hospitals
In some cases, healthcare providers may also be liable:
- Failure to warn patients about known device risks and complications;
- Improper implantation or surgical technique that contributes to device failure;
- Inadequate follow-up monitoring for device complications;
- Continuing to use recalled devices after safety warnings are issued.
These cases may involve both product liability claims against manufacturers and medical malpractice claims against healthcare providers.
Damages in Defective Device Cases
Defective medical devices can cause devastating injuries that impact every aspect of your life. Our Houston attorneys fight for full compensation covering all your losses.
Medical Costs & Future Care
Healthcare expenses from defective medical devices can be enormous:
- Revision surgery costs to remove or replace the defective device;
- Diagnostic testing including imaging, blood work, and biopsies;
- Hospitalization and recovery from device-related complications;
- Long-term medical monitoring for ongoing health effects;
- Physical therapy and rehabilitation to regain function and mobility.
Pain, Suffering & Loss of Quality of Life
Beyond financial losses, defective medical devices cause significant personal suffering:
- Physical pain and discomfort from device complications and revision surgeries;
- Emotional distress from betrayed trust in medical technology;
- Lost wages and earning capacity due to disability or time off work;
- Loss of enjoyment of life when devices prevent normal activities;
- Impact on relationships and family life from ongoing medical issues.
Our experienced product liability attorneys work with medical and economic experts to fully document and value your damages.
How Much Is My Houston Medical Device Case Worth?
The value of defective medical device cases varies significantly based on several factors unique to your situation:
Factors that increase case value:
- Severity of injuries and need for multiple revision surgeries;
- Young age at time of device implantation;
- Clear evidence of manufacturer knowledge about device defects;
- Significant impact on your ability to work and earn income;
- Strong medical evidence linking the device to your injuries.
Factors that may limit recovery:
- Federal preemption that shields manufacturers from certain claims;
- Statute of limitations issues if too much time has passed;
- Pre-existing medical conditions that contributed to complications;
- Limited damages in cases involving older patients or minor injuries.
Many defective medical device cases result in settlements ranging from hundreds of thousands to millions of dollars, depending on the specific circumstances.
Get a realistic assessment of your case value. Our Houston defective medical device attorneys provide honest evaluations during your free consultation.
Time Limits & Federal Preemption
Understanding deadlines and federal law limitations is crucial for protecting your right to compensation.
Statutes of Limitation & Repose
Texas law imposes strict deadlines for filing defective medical device lawsuits under Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code:
- Two-year statute of limitations from when you discovered or should have discovered the injury under Section 16.003;
- Statute of repose may bar claims filed more than 15 years after device manufacture under Section 16.012;
- Discovery rule may extend deadlines if device defects were hidden or not immediately apparent;
- Continuing treatment doctrine may toll the statute in ongoing doctor-patient relationships.
How Preemption Affects Claims
Federal preemption can limit or eliminate claims against certain medical device manufacturers:
- PMA devices with FDA approval may be protected from most state law claims;
- 510(k) devices generally remain subject to state product liability laws;
- Parallel claims that don’t conflict with FDA requirements may still proceed;
- Supreme Court decisions continue to evolve this area of law.
Don’t let time limits destroy your case. Contact our Houston defective medical device lawyers immediately to protect your legal rights.
Related Resources
- Defective Drug and Pharmaceutical Lawyers: Learn about dangerous medications and pharmaceutical lawsuits involving defective drugs.
- Valsartan Lawsuit: Find out about contaminated blood pressure medication that caused cancer in thousands of patients.
- Elmiron Lawsuit: Understand legal options for patients who developed serious eye damage from long-term Elmiron use.
- Houston Healthcare Liability Lawyer: Explore your rights when healthcare providers cause harm through negligence or malpractice.
- Houston Catastrophic Injury Attorney: Get help for life-altering injuries that require extensive medical care and long-term disability support.
- Houston Wrong Medication & Prescription Lawyer: Learn about claims involving pharmacy errors and incorrect prescription medications.
Defective Medical Device FAQs
Do I Need to Join an MDL?
Whether to join a multidistrict litigation (MDL) depends on your specific device and circumstances. MDLs combine similar cases for efficient pre-trial proceedings but maintain individual case values. Our attorneys evaluate whether MDL participation benefits your case or if individual litigation is more appropriate. Some advantages of MDL include shared discovery costs and coordinated expert witnesses, while individual cases may resolve faster.
What If the Device Was Recalled?
An FDA recall strengthens your case by proving the manufacturer acknowledged safety problems, but it doesn’t automatically guarantee compensation. You still must prove the recalled device caused your specific injuries and damages. Our Houston defective medical device attorneys use recall information to build stronger cases, but each claim requires individual evaluation based on your medical records and circumstances.
Can I Sue My Doctor as Well as the Manufacturer?
Yes, you may have claims against both the device manufacturer and your healthcare providers if they failed to properly warn you about risks, implanted the device incorrectly, or continued using recalled devices. These parallel claims require different legal strategies: product liability law for manufacturers and medical malpractice law for healthcare providers. Our attorneys coordinate both types of claims to maximize your recovery.
